
The AI leadership gap: Who’s falling behind and why
The AI leadership gap: Who’s falling behind and why

AI isn’t optional anymore. It’s here, it’s moving fast, and the pressure to act is growing. But what’s the reality inside organisations across Australia and New Zealand?
We asked 864 business leaders and technology professionals how their teams are preparing for AI. What we found was revealing: while belief in AI’s potential is high, true readiness is rare, and strategy is the missing piece.
Only 1 in 20 say their organisation is responding “extremely well” to AI
Just 4.9% of survey participants feel their organisation is responding to the changing AI landscape “extremely well”. While nearly a third say their company is doing “quite well,” the most common response was neutral. A lack of clarity and ownership is holding many back.
“There is an executive urgency,” said one respondent, “but our leaders lack vision and strategic thinking.”
Despite AI dominating conversations, only 16.7% of participants say it’s treated as a high strategic priority. In fact, nearly a quarter aren’t sure how AI is prioritised at all.
These numbers paint a clear picture: most organisations are still in reactive mode, watching the hype unfold and unsure how to move forward.
Experimentation is happening, but often in silos
While some teams are getting hands-on with AI, few have an organisation-wide strategy. Only 30.2% of respondents say their company has a dedicated team working on AI initiatives. The rest either don’t, aren’t sure, or are still in the planning stage.
“With only 36% of organisations currently dedicating teams to AI initiatives,” says Tom Mackintosh, Managing Director of Solve by Talent, “this leaves a huge opportunity for the other 64% to catch up and leverage its potential. Building the right AI teams can transform businesses from improving efficiency to driving innovation, the opportunities can be endless.”
When we asked who’s currently driving AI adoption, the responses were scattered:
- 31% said IT or tech departments
- 18.4% said individual departments are experimenting independently
- Just 16.7% said executive leadership is leading the charge
The result? A lot of isolated activity, but little cohesion. AI is being tested, but not yet scaled.
As Cameron Robinson, Head of Enterprise Solutions at Solve by Talent, puts it:
“The leaders making the greatest inroads implementing AI are the ones who’ve educated themselves about the opportunity it presents and are firmly glass-half-full about a future where AI is commonplace.
“They also aren’t sitting waiting for someone else to make a decision. They see the opportunity to bring a change for good in their own job, team and department, let alone the whole company, and they are taking action to capitalise on it.”
The strategy gap is stalling transformation
We asked what areas companies plan to transform with AI in the next 12 months. Nearly half of respondents (47.8%) said they “aren’t sure”. That uncertainty stands in stark contrast to the 90% of business leaders who believe AI will positively impact their teams in the next two years.
It’s not that organisations don’t care, it’s that many seem to not know where to start.
“The hype drowns out the noise,” one business leader told us. “I need an AI strategy like I need a stapler strategy or an office chair strategy. These are tools to achieve aims, not aims in themselves.”
Workforce planning is lagging behind
Despite growing headlines about AI-driven change, most organisations aren’t yet integrating AI into their workforce strategies:
- Only 12.3% plan to hire a dedicated AI specialist or leader
- Only 12.1% are actively using AI to evolve roles or reduce manual work
- 22.9% say AI isn’t impacting their workforce planning at all
But for those starting to explore the shift, the focus is turning to skills, particularly in data, infrastructure, and platform engineering.
“Implementing AI doesn’t mean you need to immediately go and hire a team of people who know how to build AI agents,” says Cameron Robinson, Head of Enterprise Solutions at Solve by Talent. “To start with, you can implement AI well by simply ensuring you’ve got a good handle on what AI-enabled features and functionality your current (and future) tech vendors and advisory partners are already capable of delivering for you.”
“Embracing AI is not optional,” said one respondent. “You will be putting yourself at a disadvantage if you don’t.”
This isn’t a tech problem, it’s a leadership one
AI is a tool, but it’s a tool that forces change. The challenge now is strategic: aligning teams, clarifying goals, and leading with intent.
Leadership means:
- Setting a clear direction and aligning AI with business priorities
- Empowering teams to experiment safely and share learnings
- Investing in foundational skills, not just flashy tools
- Creating space for ethical, thoughtful AI adoption, and not just speed
The organisations doing this well are already seeing momentum build. The rest have an opportunity to catch up, but time is a factor.
If you’re wondering where your team sits in all this, our full report dives deeper into the data from 864 professionals across Australia and New Zealand. You’ll find insight into what’s really happening in workplaces and how to lead the way forward. Access the findings here.